| The official state
gazette, Reshumot, has just published new conversion regulations that
grant the president of the rabbinical high court, Chief Rabbi Shlomo
Amar, exclusive control over the conversion courts and their
administration. The Prime
Minister's Office – supposedly responsible for conversion policy –
reportedly didn't even know about the changes until they were
published.
Among what have been described as
"draconian measures" is the prerogative to annul conversions
retroactively in the event of their being deemed "mistaken."
This directive reminds me of a case
that was heard in the Haifa rabbinical divorce courts a number of
years ago. The wife was an Orthodox convert to Judaism. Since her
husband was able to prove that she did not observe Shabbat rigorously,
he succeeded in persuading the court to annul her conversion.
If her conversion was invalid, so was
his marriage to her. As such, the divorce court ruled that he had the
right to remarry without issuing his former wife with a get (divorce
bill) and meeting the financial obligations of a divorce agreement
with her.
Many would question whether there is
any halachic basis whatsoever for the ex post facto annulment of a
conversion. Once a Jew always a Jew – and that goes for converts as
well.
The truth is that Rabbi Amar's new
conversion regulations are indicative of an ongoing struggle between
the chief rabbinate and the Prime Minister's Office over who shall
have jurisdiction over conversion procedures in Israel.
Attempts by the prime minister to ease
the process and make the option of conversion more accessible to the
300,000 immigrants from the former USSR who are not Jewish have met
with strong resistance from most of the Orthodox rabbinical
establishment.
Judaism is an exclusive club, they will
tell you, and all clubs have their entry qualifications.
All would be well and good if people
were fighting to join the club – but the opposite is the case. Rather
than people running to adopt Judaism, they are fleeing from it.
A recent report from the United States
indicated that almost 50 percent of American college students who
affiliate with Hillel have only one Jewish parent. While it is
encouraging that they choose to associate with Hillel, the figures are
an inevitable reflection of the high rate of intermarriage within
Diaspora Jewry.
HOWEVER, ISRAEL cannot sit back and rub
her hands smugly in the belief that her society is immune to the
threat to Jewish identity of an open, pluralistic and largely secular
society.
The story is told that while
Palestinian leader Jibril Rajoub was sitting in an Israeli prison he
saw a prison warder eating falafel in pitta bread. Said Rajoub: "Why
are you eating that? Don't you know it's Pessah?"
The warder shrugged his shoulders
indifferently. Rajoub is reported as remarking that when he saw that
he realized that the State of Israel would destroy itself.
While the reports of our impending
death are greatly exaggerated, most would agree that we must do
everything in our power to increase the observance of Judaism and
encourage would-be converts to join us.
For instance, the new rules require
that conversion candidates maintain "a Torah-observant lifestyle" even
though the majority of Jews worldwide do not live their lives in an
Orthodox fashion.
Setting unrealistic criteria for
conversion and raising innumerable barriers does not increase the
observance of Judaism – just the opposite; it encourages potential
converts give up.
Day after day, as director of the
rabbinical court of the Israel Council of Progressive Rabbis, I deal
with applications for conversion. Some come from those who have fallen
foul of the labyrinth the Orthodox rabbinical establishment has
created.
Fortunately, conversions performed
under our auspices are now also recognized by the State of Israel for
registration purposes. Reform converts are at last accepted as Jews by
the Jewish state.
Nevertheless, Rabbi Amar's new
regulations are a further reminder that it is high time for Israel to
de-establish religion and enable the various streams of Judaism to
compete on an equal footing.
The writer is director of the
rabbinic court of the Israel Council of Progressive Rabbis. |